Sunday, April 10, 2011

Yet Another Blogger Vs. Wordpress Article

When Internet is filled with plethora of Blogger Vs Wordpress articles which may take ages to read and at the end you will remain totally confused that who will win. Yesterday night I had a hot discussion with Shubham Gupta( author of Techquark). We both by our nature are very rigid, and stand for what we like. Though I like both blogger and wordpress but I took side of Wordpress. In the course of discussion I was unable to convince Shubham  that Wordpress is better. Shubham only had one argument "Tell me one single thing which Blogger can not do and Wordpress can?".


I had so many to tell but I was unable to frame my word to a person who is not completely aware of wordpress. Its really difficult to tell a person that what is better in Wordpress who has only half knowledge of using it. I agree that to "blogger used to guy" initial impression of Wordpress is not great, "I could do that in Blogger too". So I went by gazillions of blogs and posts analysed many of them. So without any further delay, Let the battle commence between Blogger and Wordpress.



Introduction:


Blogger:

Blogger is a blog-publishing service that allows private or multi-user blogs with time-stamped entries. It was created by Pyra Labs, which was bought by Google in 2003. Generally, the blogs are hosted by Google at subdomain of blogspot.com. Up until May 1, 2010 Blogger allowed users to publish blogs on other hosts, via FTP. All such blogs had (or still have) to be moved to Google's own servers, with domains other than blogspot.com allowed via Custom URLs.(Source: www.wikipedia.com)


Blogger's ride was not smooth all the time, even backed by Google, blogger was criticized due to many glitches it had and have. We will discus them in detail.



Wordpress:


WordPress is an open source blog tool and publishing platform powered by PHP and MySQL. It's often customized into a Content Management System (CMS). It has many features including a plug-in architecture and a template system. WordPress is used by over 13% of the 1,000,000 biggest websites.It was first released on May 27, 2003, by Matt Mullenweg as a fork of b2/cafelog. As of February 2011, version 3.0 had been downloaded over 32.5 million times.(Source: www.wikipedia.com)


Wordpress was also not flawless. But Wordpress is always adored by professionals and WebMasters. Lets see why Wordpress is one of the most successful platform in top websites.


We will test both platforms, compare them and finally rate each feature on a scale from 1 to 10. Lets see who will win.







The War:


OwnerShip


Blogger: Being a product of Google may have N number of advantages but when it comes to ownership, bloggers who blog on blogspot have nothing in hand. It is clearly mentioned in Blogspot's TOS:





  1. Google may, in its sole discretion, at any time and for any reason, terminate the Service, terminate this Agreement, or suspend or terminate your account. In the event of termination, your account will be disabled and you may not be granted access to your account or any files or other content contained in your account although residual copies of information may remain in our system for some time for back-up purposes.

  2. Unless expressly authorized in writing by Google, you agree not to reproduce, duplicate, copy, sell, trade, resell or exploit for any commercial purposes (a) any portion of the Service, (b) use of the Service, or (c) access to the Service.



When Google disables your account you have nothing in hand. Just by Googling you can get an estimate of how many blogspot bloggers have temporarily or permanently lost their blogger account, it takes a long process to activate every thing again(even if you are innocent). Here is an interesting article to read.


WordPress: Wordpress on the other hand is an opensource content management system, which you can install on any server supporting php and mysql. Installing on most of the servers are easy using fantastico, even upgrading is very easy. Once installed on your domain you are the sole owner of your blog and your account can not be disabled by any one. For professional bloggers ownership is one of the very important aspects.


Rating:


Wordpress gets 9/10 in Ownership (not given 10 because you may have to comply to TOS of your web server provider)


Blogger gets 3/10 in Ownerhip (3 rating is given due to authors having ownership over content)



Money Matters


Blogger: Blogger is absolutely free, hosted on fast Google servers and which are never down(on papers). Having your own custom domain is as easy in just 10$.


Wordpres: You can have your free Wordpress blog on www.wordpress.com with your custom domain and servers are also quiet good. With 99.99% uptime and Fast servers Wordpress do not lag far behind Google. Self hosted servers are upto you what you choose.


Rating:


Wordpress gets 8/10


Blogger gets 9/10



Branding


Blogger: For all casual and amateur bloggers Branding is not as important as to Professionals. Blogger by default has irksome navbar(you can only remove it by changing style). Even when you have a custom domain, branding is one of the big problems.



In this image you can see "page not found" error of a custom domain with blogger branding.


Wordpress: Again you have complete control here also.


Rating:


Wordpress gets 9/10


Blogger gets 6/10



Theming Capabilities


Blogger: Theming capabilities of Blogger can never come at par with Wordpress. You have very limited options with blogger. though there are very good third party themes available for Blogger but that are mostly copy of Wordpress themes. While some Wordpress themes use jquery and other technologies which make User Interface awesome. Blogger has them but there is limit.


Wordpress: On the other hand in Wordpress have infinite themes. You can make your Wordpress look like twitter( click here to check out). You even can make it as online Magazine or what ever you dream of. Switching between themes is not even 1 pie difficult. You can have 10 themes and can activate any of them with one click. (You can not do that with third party themes in Blogger)


Rating:


Wordpress gets 8/10


Blogger gets 6/10



Gadgets Vs Widgets


Here is a tie, Both Blogger and Wordpress have So many of them. Ease of use are also equal in both. So I can give both a rating of 9/10. Though I can not forget to mention that most of the third party Gadgets have files hosted on their servers, This can be a disadvantage in many ways.



SEO


This is the most important and most confusing thing, I know all the blogspot users will say that Google owns Blogspot and thus they will give the best SEO and rank up in Google. I know Logically that should happen, but this is not the case.


Content is the most important thing, The only thing which is in favor of Blogspot is "Fast indexing", but once indexing is done there are other factors which comes to play and Blogspot can not beat Wordpress in those things.


Wordpress offers plugins which can create a site map, can edit robots.txt, can aid cross linking. So Wordpress has a little upper hand in SEO. Remember one thing Google can never compromise the quality of its searches just to make blogger up in their searches, Content is most important and is the best SEO technique ;).


Rating:


Wordpress gets 6/10


Blogger gets 6/10



What Blogger does not have and Wordpress have?


Ok, Now we are back to the basic question "Tell me one single thing which Blogger can not do and Wordpress can?". I have three things which are not available on Blogger but available on Wordpress


Media Library is complete image,video and audio management system all at single place. Blogger equivalents are Picasa and Youtube. As the files are hosted n your server you have complete rights on your content.


Categories are very different from tags Wordpress have tags(Blogger equivalet is labels) as well as categories. Categories lets a blog have different channels all for different purposes.


Plugins are often compared with gadgets by Blogspot users are very unique feature of Wordpress, you can do any thing with it. Its like a magic wand. You can only know the power of it only when you will use it. As the Wordpress way it




Plugins can extend WordPress to do almost anything you can imagine.



You can compare plugin to a software which extends capability of operating  system. Plugins have the ability to transform the WordPress platform into a separate system of its own. For example, there are certain plugins like shopping cart or membership site plugins that would transform a WordPress blog into a membership site. With some more plugins like payment portal, a simple blog turns into a sales letter.[source]



Where Wordpress lags


Wordpress has serious security concerns, though new versions are highly secure but still they can effect your blog if you do not have a backup. But We have seen very less attacks on some very famous websites, thus we can say that security flaws can be ignored. And as Wordpress is opensource security patches comes instantaneously.



The Verdict


I know any Blogger user/lover will not agree with me despite of any point I will put forward. But Wordpress is for professional bloggers Blogspot is not. Blogspot is best for new bloggers who do not know any thing about SEO, managing traffic etc., Blogger is ready steady go blog management system. Wordpress is much more than that, it is like a clay you can give it any shape you want. You have the total control.  I personally Like Worpress as well as Blogger. But Wordpress out beats handsomely in managing my content.

2 comments:

  1. I helped you change many points in your post which you were not aware of.

    I can have discussion against each point, but it will be a vicious circle !

    Anyways nice post dude ! Keep up the good work ! The only point which can earn point from me was the branding point !

    ReplyDelete
  2. nice research done :) ...Leaving all the technical issues aside...even i like word press without any biasness :)

    ReplyDelete